March 20, 2018

"So many writers have produced 'I went offline, and here is what I learned' stories that they became a tedious cliché years ago."

"Cliché or no, however, those stories had one thing in common: the writers of them all actually went offline. Farhad Manjoo, technology columnist for The New York Times, took a different tack. He didn’t go offline at all: he just said he did, in a widely discussed column. Manjoo wrote about what he learned from his two months away from social media, and dispensed avuncular advice to his readers about the benefits of slowing down one’s news consumption. But he didn’t really unplug from social media at all. The evidence is right there in his Twitter feed, just below where he tweeted out his column: Manjoo remained a daily, active Twitter user throughout the two months he claims to have gone cold turkey, tweeting many hundreds of times, perhaps more than 1,000. In an email interview... he stuck to his story, essentially arguing that the gist of what he wrote remains true, despite the tweets throughout his self-imposed hiatus...."

Writes Dan Mitchell at Columbia Journalism Review.

27 comments:

Kevin said...

Fake turtles all the way down.

Kevin said...

he stuck to his story, essentially arguing that the gist of what he wrote remains true, despite the tweets throughout his self-imposed hiatus...."

So it's just like Trump and Russian "collusion".

Big Mike said...

I’m shocked, shocked!

MadisonMan said...

If you have the right political viewpoint, you're allowed to lie. And the Times won't care.

Quaestor said...

The lying tag is redundant in this context, don't you think?

traditionalguy said...

You got to watch those "writers" cranking out 50 shades of fiction and calling them reality stories. They are just the most fictional "works."

They remind me of the out of town lawyers who are paid more when they bring the witnesses with them.

BarrySanders20 said...

He identifies as being offline. Don't be a H8ter.

richlb said...

Fake but accurate.

Big Mike said...

@richlb, that is the standard in the media ever since Rather, is it not?

And is your moniker short for “rich liberal”?

Jim Grey said...

Did he write nothing but original first-level (not reply or retweet) tweets? Then they could all have been scheduled in advance, or if written in realtime sent through something like HootSuite. He could genuinely never have actually *consumed* Twitter during that time.

Rob said...

In Manjoo’s defense, he didn’t compliment any employees on their looks, so there’s that.

rhhardin said...

I don't have a cell phone so am spiritually offline whenever I'm not in the computer room.

Ann Althouse said...

"I don't have a cell phone so am spiritually offline whenever I'm not in the computer room."

I guess you also don't have a laptop.

rhhardin said...

My computer is a laptop but is used as a desktop, with external monitor keyboard etc.

Tethered to the room.

rhhardin said...

The laptop I replaced a couple of months ago was covered in a thick layer of dust, from its not being closed or touched in ten years of 24/7 operation. Its HD finally failed, and at 30GB HD 1MB ram, was perhaps not the best size for modern browsers.

Replaced it with a 5yo laptop.

Mark said...

He has always been suspect, more full of truthiness than fact.

At Slate it became clear he is a total Apple fanboy who loves everything with that logo on it ... though he was in complete denial. I assumed he left Slate because they had enough, hope WaPo lets him go.

On the internet, no one knows you are a dog. But they do note whem you post from your username.

tim in vermont said...

He obviously has an addiction problem. I can relate.

tim in vermont said...

rh was heating his house by mining Bitcoin.

Ann Althouse said...

"My computer is a laptop but is used as a desktop, with external monitor keyboard etc. Tethered to the room."

This is the equivalent of a hardline (non-cordless) telephone.

There used to be a specific place for things. There was only one TV and it was in the TV room. The bed went in the "bed room."

tcrosse said...

If you can't make it good make it up.

Fernandinande said...

Farhad Manjoo

"Thank you, come again!"

Kevin said...
Fake turtles all the way down.


And thank you for telling me what I was trying to think, even though the emotional struggles of newspaper writers are probably interesting.

the 4chan Guy who reads Althouse said...

The bed went in the "bed room."

And the whips and restraining chains went into the basement.

The Germans have a word for this.

tcrosse said...

There used to be a specific place for things.

There still is a kitchen and a bathroom.

Mike (MJB Wolf) said...

Sure #FakeNews begat #FakeFeatureStories which begat #FakeOpinion in the Trump era. The journalism “profession” continues its downward spiral from the Fourth Estate to the fifth dimension.

the 4chan Guy who reads Althouse said...

Back in the Betamax3000 days I went a day without commenting on Althouse.

As Lou Reed once warbled, "Those were different times."

Lour Reed also sang "Oh do it, do it, oh just, just, just do it, bless Sister Ray sir, go on!"

So one can pick and choose.

The Germans have a word for this.

n.n said...

Wait a few years (i.e. frame shift). Everything old is new again.

tim in vermont said...

Last David Foster Wallace comment, I promise, but if you watch The End of the Tour, the movie about an interview with him not long before he hanged himself, the addiction in his book was clearly a metaphor for his addiction to television, which he said was not sexy enough to write about.